Saturday, May 13, 2006

Another old diary: On self-censorship

They are there a couple of days a month, outside the local shopping mall. Maybe it's more like a day a week. Conspicuous in their camouflage gear and close-cropped hair. With their ridiculous little tank, their tents, their guns and their glossy recruiting literature. All terribly neat and tidy.

Most people here do not talk to them. So they just stand there all day waiting around looking silly.
When I see them, my throat tightens.
When I walk past, I look at them closely, my expression inexpressive.
The clouds seem a little closer, the sun a little dimmer.
The day more grey.
When I first noticed them, I thought, "Good. Very thin pickings here.
Let them waste just as much time here as they like.
May they come in droves with their conspicuous camouflage gear and close-cropped hair, their ridiculous little tank, their tents, their guns and their glossy recruiting literature every day, and stand about, talking to nobody and looking silly. The more the merrier."

Even if my throat tightens, my face grows guarded and the day seems strangely grey. Given that the sun is shining and all.

But I was just very, very stupid.

The last time they were there, outside the local shopping mall, I realised at last why they were there. Most everyone else walking by knew already, I'm quite sure. One way. Or the other.

For despite the conspicuous camouflage gear, the close-cropped hair, the ridiculous little tank, the tents, the shiny, shiny guns and the glossy recruiting literature, they were not there for recruits.
Officially, yes. Sure.

But not in fact.

For even the most lax of superior officers must at some point notice that despite their regular appearance outside the local shopping mall in conspicuous camouflage, with the close-cropped hair, the ridiculous little tank, the tents, the shiny, shiny guns and the glossy recruiting literature, there is nary a new recruit in sight.

(And all of a sudden, from this new vantage point, the mysterious uniformity of their whiteness -- which had been a mystery to me -- snapped into place, like the last stubborn corner of an old Tupperware box)

They are There To Show a Presence.
Trooping the Colours.
Waving the Flag.
Showing the Sullen Natives (that's "them" and who knows, perhaps it will also be latecomer me) What's What.

Empires cast long shadows. Though many years have passed since its eclipse, the sun has not yet set on this one. Still, it seeks reflected glory.

The second week of Ramadan is beginning
and it would be fair to say that this has been a difficult year.
My acquaintances,
politely singled out for baggage checks,
tell of suspicious looks.
Their expressions speak of biting their tongues until they bleed, even though they do not say so.

Usually it's busy outside the shopping mall, today it's quiet.
Lots of people staying at home,
calling numbers that don't answer today.
Waiting.

But there they were.
Outside the local shopping mall,
in conspicuous camouflage and close-cropped hair, with their ridiculous little tank, their tents, their shiny, shiny guns, the glossy recruiting literature and nary a new recruit in sight.

They stand there all day, looking menacing.
When I see them, my throat tightens.
When I walk past, I stare coldly.
Those clouds look like thunder. The sun is grey.

12 Comments:

Blogger dove said...

At the risk of going meta, can we have a bit of a chat/debate/argument about my proposed exercise of the dictatorial power of censorship?
It seems at least obliquely applicable.

I'd welcome your thoughts (on everything in general, of course, including the diary to which this is attached) but particularly, I'd welcome your thoughts on the issue of ad hominem attacks.

What it boils down to is that I don't want this site to be yet another place where people feel free to launch personal attacks on DTF. Or indeed, on any of you or me for that matter. But I think DTF is something of the proverbial canary in the mine. And also -- perhaps it shouldn't matter but actually I find it does -- DTF is someone I explicitly told to make himself at home here.

Anyway, when out and about on my travels I occasionally see BNP leaflets or Combat 18 stickers, I stop what I'm doing and tear down all the ones I can find. At the earliest opportunity, I then report it to the folks who deal with hate incidents, so that someone else can come out to check if I missed any.

That's censorship -- the suppression of expression. There's little point in mincing words about it. And what I'm proposing to do here -- to delete new posts if I consider them to be ad hominem attacks -- is censorship as well.

If I had a moral problem with censorship in such circumstances, I wouldn't have proposed it: while I value freedom of speech, I don't value it to the exclusion of all else.

However some of you may reason differently and may wish to try and argue that I should have a moral problem with censorship in these circumstances, so I thought I'd seek your advice.

Others may simply have (as I do, frankly) pragmatic concerns about inter-rater reliability (or rather the lack of it).

Anyway -- what do you think?

5/13/2006 12:15 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

From poco:

Ooooh!! Meta!! (rubs her hands with glee)

Slightly OT, but let me share my experience with blogger--tried to do a new sign in and it didn't like my username. So I changed my username, and blogger didn't the second one either, or the third. At this point I firmly believe it is a personal enmity, or, hmmm, maybe I am jumping to conclusions-- blogger just believes it is being cute and funny and devilishly tricksterish, and can't understand why I am not giggling delightedly.

Regarding the censorship issue, I agree with dove and nanette--I have never been a free speech extremist. So you are not going to get any arguments on that issue from me. It is dove's nest and she gets to decide.

Initially, I had thought that the anon-other was more of an irritation and the last posting was best ignored as being beneath contempt, but on re-reading dove's and nanette's posts I realize that drive-by postings such as anon's poison the nest and nasty, personal, anon attacks need to be nipped in the bud. (okay, too much pastoral imagery here)

5/13/2006 5:55 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

From poco:

damn!damn!damn! dove, can you erase the repetitions, please.

5/13/2006 5:58 pm  
Blogger dove said...

Done, poco. Love the image of blogger as devilishly tricksterish.

Thanks to both of you for offering advice on this -- I'm hoping DTF and some of others who stop by sometimes might feel like chiming in as well.

"It's too easy, online, to not only engage in ad hominem (and anonymous) attacks, but also to think one must accept them as part of the online culture or something... in fact, some places thrive on stuff like that."

I think this is really important, Nannette. Don't have much to add to it, but that business of particular styles of interaction being naturalised or normalised is one I find really interesting.

5/13/2006 6:59 pm  
Blogger dove said...

Slow on the uptake my foot.
But oooh, I like peppermints. I could probably even manage a squawk for peppermints.

Well,I don't think I want ad hominem attacks here. After all, I can't think of any other context where I'd provide a conduit for their broader dissemination.

And I must admit to having found Ms. Anonymous's last post amusing in light of the posts preceding. I'm fairly sure I wasn't supposed to be amused though.

I've been thinking about your dilemma lately. I don't think I have any answers though. I do have a desire to remind you of that which you already know: that people, whether sitting at their keyboards or not sitting at their keyboards are -- however much they may wish or believe otherwise -- moral agents who are responsible for their choices, constrained though these may be.

While I know you're well capable of fending off dangerous trolls, I think that being hated can be pretty exhausting. Stay well.

5/14/2006 7:29 pm  
Blogger dove said...

Thankyou for this Nanette - it's really useful to be reminded that communities can be intentional.

And you've also reminded me that my own history in a way. I've been thinking of online writing as something I began in 2004 after November, but actually, I had spent quite a long time on a rather intense little BBS back on the 90s. It was an extreme example of 'mytown syndrome' in its way -- it's users not lived in the same otwn, but were from the same -- well I'm not quite sure what to call it really, not quite a commune, not quite a society, not quite a culture, but something related to all of those things. And looking back one realises that it was and is quite carefully tended.

5/16/2006 1:29 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello, Good resources here. Very useful. [url=http://lipus.org/lipitor.html]lipitor[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/zithromax.html]zithromax[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/soma.html]soma[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/viagra.html]viagra[/url] [url=http://lipus.o
rg/zoloft.html]zoloft[/url] and this :[url=http://lipus.org/doctor-lipitor-vs-zocor.html]doctor lipitor vs zocor[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/lipitor-loss-memory.html]lipitor loss memory[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/grapefruit-lipitor.html]grapefruit lipitor[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/danger-lipitor.html]danger lipitor[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/joint-lipitor-pain.html]joint lipitor pain[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/effects-lipitor-negative-side.html]effects lipitor negative side[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/grapefruit-juice-lipitor.html]grapefruit juice lipitor[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/lipitor-memory-thief.html]lipitor memory thief[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/blister-effects-lipitor-side.html]blister effects lipitor side[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/ache-lipitor-muscle.html]ache lipitor muscle[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/lipitor-rhabdomyolysis.html]lipitor rhabdomyolysis[/url] [url=htt
p://lipus.org/lipitor-lovastatin-vs.html]lipitor lovastatin vs[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/cramp-leg-lipitor.html]cramp leg lipitor[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/expiration-lipitor-patent.html]expiration lipitor patent[/url] and [url=http://lipus.org/zithromax-antibiotic.html]zithromax antibiotic[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/zithromax-z-pak.html]zithromax z pak[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/zithromax-side-effects.html]zithromax side effects[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/zithromax-generic.html]zithromax generic[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/buy-zithromax.html]buy zithromax[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/zithromax-dosage.html]zithromax dosage[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/sinus-infection-zithromax.html]sinus infection zithromax[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/zithromax-and-pregnancy.html]zithromax and pregnancy[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/zithromax-for-strep-throat.html]zithromax for strep throat[/ur
l] [url=http://lipus.org/zithromax-zpac.html]zithromax zpac[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/zithromax.html]zithromax[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/ash-of-soma.html]ash of soma[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/akane-soma.html]akane soma[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/soma-350mg.html]soma 350mg[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/soma-triathlon.html]soma triathlon[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/argento-soma.html]argento soma[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/ash-lyric-soma.html]ash lyric soma[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/soma-by-chicos.html]soma by chicos[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/divine-hallucinogen-soma.html]divine hallucinogen soma[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/zoloft-side-effects-mayo.html]zoloft side effects mayo[/url] and very creative :[url=http://lipus.org/zoloft-for-premature-ejaculation.html]zoloft for premature ejaculation[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/weaning-off-zoloft.html]weaning off zoloft[/url] [url=http://lipus
.org/zoloft-litigation.html]zoloft litigation[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/ocd-zoloft.html]ocd zoloft[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/zoloft-night-sweats.html]zoloft night sweats[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/zoloft-and-pms.html]zoloft and pms[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/zoloft-pmdd.html]zoloft pmdd[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/buy-viagra.html]buy viagra[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/cheap-viagra.html]cheap viagra[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/generic-viagra.html]generic viagra[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/buy-viagra-online.html]buy viagra online[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/viagra-online.html]viagra online[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/female-viagra.html]female viagra[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/order-viagra.html]order viagra[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/discount-viagra.html]discount viagra[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/blindness-viagra.html]blindness viagra[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/branded-viagra.html]branded viagra[/url] [url=http://lipus.org/gel-tab-viagra.html]gel tab viagra[/url] Regards

2/05/2007 4:05 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thanks for the welcome Pills diet & marriage ! [url=http://pills1.org/claritin/index2.html]index2.html.[/url] It`s map s
ite [url=http://pills1.org/diflucan/index1.html]index1.html.[/url] and [url=http://pills1.org/lipitor/index4.html]index4.html.[/url] and [url=http://pills1.org/neurontin/index2.html]index2.html.[/url] [url=http://pill
s1.org/sildenafil/index.html]index.html.[/url] [url=http://pills1.org/zoloft/zoloft-litigation.html]zoloft litigation[/url] [url=http://pills1.org/zoloft/zoloft.html]zoloft[/url] [url=http://pills1.org/claritin/claritin-d12hour.html]claritin d12hour[/url] [url=http://pills1.org/claritin/claritin-reditab.html]claritin reditab[/url] else [url=http://pills1.org/claritin/claritin-interaction-valerian.html]claritin interaction valerian[/url] [
url=http://pills1.org/diflucan/diflucan-pahrmacy.html]diflucan pahrmacy[/url] [url=http://pills1.org/imitrex/generic-imitrex.html]generic imitrex[/url] [url=http://pills1.org/lipitor/joint-lipitor-pain.html]joint lipitor pain[/url] [url=http://pills1.org/lipitor/grapefruit-juice-lipitor.html]grapefruit juice lipitor[/url] [url=http://pills1.org/lipitor/expiration-lipitor-patent.html]expiration lipitor patent[/url] [url=http://pills1.org/neurontin/neurontin-node-swollen.html]neurontin node swollen[/url] [url=http://pills1.org/sildenafil/sildenafil-tablet-zenegra.html]sildenafil tablet zenegra[/url] and [url=http://pills1.org/sildenafil/fissure-rectal-sildenafil-zenegra.html]fissure rectal sildenafil zenegra[/url] [url=http://pills1.org/sildenafil/congestion-nasal-sildenafil-zenegra.html]congestion nasal sildenafil zenegra[/url] Sincerely

2/07/2007 6:19 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi people! I'm rather fat woman and whole my life I fight with my weight.
index.html index1.html soma soma 350mg and argento soma buy soma and aura soma prescription soma other soma san diego ca and very creative : index.html index1.html cialis online cialis generic viagra cialis free cialis order 20mg cialis cialis free buy cheap cialis generic online tadalafil vs buy cialis online viagra cheapest cialis online and this :cialis comparison levitra viagra cialis lilly other cialis me.com cialis sale generic cialis online or index.html buy viagra cheap viagra generic viagra buy viagra online female viagra and inurl trackback viagra gel tab viagra viagra viagra cialis levitra viagra viagra alternative viagra pill viagra uk and this :natural viagra alternative order viagra air travel look this index.html 2dir tramadol buy tramadol or online tramadol order tramadol and this :cod tramadol information tramadol and effects hydrochloride side tramadol and this : |index.html zoloft side effects mayo zoloft for premature ejaculation weaning off zoloft zoloft litigation look this zoloft pmdd zoloft zoloft zoloft common side effects and look this lexapro vs zoloft cool info : zoloft success story cool info : index.html and elseclaritin d12 claritin pregnancy generic claritin d cool info : claritin commercial or index.html buy zithromax antibiotic child zithromax interesting:dose pediatric zithromax other index.html zyrtec d12 hour zyrtec allergy medication or purchase zyrtec and this : index.html diflucan dosage how does diflucan work imitrex dosage imitrex medication side effects index1.html grapefruit juice lipitor 20mg lipitor alternative lipitor drug generic lipitor lipitor online 300mg neurontin neurontin neurontin anxiety neurontin side affect effects of neurontin citrate sildenafil ups canada citrate sildenafil zenegra 100mg citrate sildenafil zenegra sildenafil side effects sildenafil works zenegra

. Much respect!

2/10/2007 6:55 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

tamiflu cheap perscription drugsteen cock suckertamifluteen cock suckercialis worksteen cock suckercuntteen cock sucker

2/10/2007 1:08 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

平塚 売主
不眠症 治療
賃貸事務所 東京
ハーレー
商標調査
バイク便
名古屋 ホテル
アトピー性皮膚炎
ブライダルエステ
ボイストレーニング 福岡
宮原 一戸建て
サイディング
昭島市 一戸建て
オーダーカーテン
低価格 住宅
千葉市 忘年会
バーチャルオフィスを広める社長のブログ

介護 募集
バスト・豊胸
賃貸 なんば
会計 監査
婚活パーティー
マイクロバブル
駐車場経営
カードプリンタ ニスカ
がん治療
社会人入試
英語 転職
沖縄エステ
カード ポイント還元
ウェディングドレス 通販
医院開業 資金
風船
加圧トレーニング

11/30/2009 1:14 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

五反田 賃貸
東京湾 クルージング
妊娠中
結納
あきる野 不動産
ウェルカムボード 手作り
八王子 駐車場
ニュージーランド大学院留学
ゴルフレッスン多摩
リノベーション
部品トレー
ウコン
ハードコンタクト
都筑区 不動産
ビザ申請
中古医療機器 輸出
ゴルフ会員権
審美歯科 料金
トランクルーム
ウェルカムボード
派遣会社
リンナイ給湯器
英会話
相続 横浜市
生い立ちビデオ
恋愛 相談
カード現金化 東京
店舗設計 大阪
増毛
パーカー

11/30/2009 1:15 pm  

Post a Comment

<< Home